Physical chemistry, thermodynamics, structure and change. Philosophers of science also look at issues within particular sciences, such as the interpretation of quantum mechanics, the status of evolutionary theory, or problems of observation in psychology. In particular i show that duhem rejected poincares account of scientific language, le roys view that laws are definitions, and the conventionalists use of simplicity as the criterion of theory choice. Duhem objects strongly to poincares claim that the. An experiment in physics can never condemn an isolated hypothesis but only a whole theoretical group the physicist who carries out an experiment, or gives a report of one, implicitly recognizes the. The status of hiddenvariable theories sciencedirect. In his the aim and structure of physical theory 1914, duhem critiqued the baconian notion of crucial experiments. Philosophers of science also look at issues within particular sciences, such as the interpretation of quantum mechanics, the status of evolutionary theory, or. A reinterpretation by morten soberg1 august 19th, 2002 abstract. As a physicist, he championed energetics, holding generalized thermodynamics as foundational for physical theory, that is, thinking that all of chemistry and physics, including mechanics, electricity, and magnetism, should be derivable from thermodynamic first principles.
According to this critique, an experiment in physics is not simply an observation, but rather an interpretation of. Founded on april 7, 2009, our purpose is to study the writing of pierre duhem and stanley l. Nov 15, 2011 the duhem society founded on april 7, 2009, our purpose is to study the writing of pierre duhem and stanley l. The experiment was performed successfully and cod values have been determined in the above table. The history of science alone can keep the physicist from the mad ambitions of dogmatism as well as the despair of pyrrhonian scepticism. Hacking, representing and intervening, and scienti. Pierre duhem physical theory and experiment the physicist who carries out an experiment, or gives a report of one, implicitly recognizes the accu racy of a whole group of theories. However, as dudley shapere pointed out, this view is mistaken. Firstly, the fact that we always test our theory in light of other theories made duhem notice that the phenomena we are going to observe and the way we interpret them is always driven by theory. Certain fundamental hypotheses of physical theory cannot be contradicted by any experiment, because they constitute in reality definitions, and because certain expressions in the physicists usage take their meaning only through them p. But these presupposed theories need not be identical to the theory under test. The logic of scientific explanation and theory construction.
The chapters and page numbers referred to in this syllabus are from. Pierre duhem was one of the great figures in french science, a devoted teacher, and a distinguished scholar of the history and philosophy of science. Empedocles, newton, the centrifugal force and their bucket. By considering duhem s historical context i show that his epistemological views were already formed before the crisis occured. Bernadette bensaudevincent has argued convincingly that this background shaped their philosophical outlook, in contrast. Light fresnel diffraction experimental study set up an arrangement in the lab to observe light fresnel diffraction from a slit. Pdf to text batch convert multiple files software please purchase personal license.
I suggest that it is the task of the logic of scien tific discovery, or the logic of knowledge, to give a the logic of discuvery london. Pierre duhem 18611916 was a french physicist and historian and philosopher of science. The theory of partial differential equations and the related areas of variational calculus, fourier analysis, potential theory, and vector analysis are perhaps most closely associated with mathematical physics. Everitt distinguishes airys phenomenological law from. These were developed intensively from the second half of the 18th century by, for example, dalembert, euler, and lagrange until the 1930s. Physical theory and experiment part 2, chapter 6, in the aim and structure of physical theory, princeton university press, p. Campbell interpretation of physics rudolf carnap logic of explanation. Physical theory and experiment duhem two dogmas of empiricism quine hw 3 is due on 1110 iv 1115.
Foucaults experiment was not the crucial experiment that arago thought he saw in it, but by resisting wave optics for a longer timeoptics for a longer time biot would have been lackingwould have been lacking in good sense. Whether our goals are practical or theoretical, our pursuit of such goals ought to be informed by at least some of our beliefs about the environment in which such a pursuit takes place. Pierre duhems the aim and structure of physical theory. Observation in patterns of discovery, cambridge university press, 1972, ch. Chemical changes are changes substances undergo when they become new or different substances. Duhem, physical theory and experiment secs 14, 810, ereserves 31 oct poppers falsi cationism popper, the problem of induction, ereserves godfreysmith, ch 4 5 nov kuhn and normal science godfreysmith, ch 5 7 nov kuhn and revolutions paper due godfreysmith, ch 6 12 nov lakatos, feyerabend godfreysmith, ch 7. Introduction the analysis of experimentation is a relatively new trend in history and philosophy of science. All who are ready to take a serious look at philosophy and history are welcome to join. Duhem also worried about underdetermination, albeit of a very different sort see stanford 2001, and added a further concern about the role played by idealizations in physical theories. In addition, both duhem and poincare were deeply impressed by the long history of repeated and radical discontinuities in the dominant theoretical. This book represents his most mature thought on a wide range of topics.
Pierre duhems concept of good sense milena ivanova 4 there are two important arguments that arise from the holistic thesis pointed by duhem. According to duhem physical theory can not reveal the unobservable reality, but still it can teach us something of the world because the more complete it becomes the more the relations it establishes among the data of observation correspond to real relations among realities. After the demise of logical positivism both disciplines tended to focus on the theoretical aspects of science and played down the. This classic work in the philosophy of physical science is an incisive and readable account of the scientific method. Physical theory 1906 and two dogmas of empiricism 1951. From aim and structure of physical theory, princeton university press, pp. Kuhn and paradigm structures chalmers, chapter 8 kuhn, excerpt from structure of scientific revolutions oct.
Additional readings, which are marked with a symbol in the schedule, will be posted to courseworks. Pierre duhem physical theory and experiment l the experimental testing of a theory does not have the same logical simplicity in physics as in physiology the sole purpose of physical theory is to provide a representation and classification of experimental laws. Introduction to part 5 lange laws and their role in scientific explanation hempel 1117. Similarly, duhem dislikes, on philosophical grounds, the idea that physical hypotheses should be drawn from experiment, without being able to offer any historical examples of this method being counterproductive, and while recognising the fruits of this method in the works of, e. Use lenses to expand a 632 nm laser beam and form a line focus source. The duhem quine thesis asserts that any empirical evaluation of a theory is in fact a composite test of several interconnected hypotheses. Recalcitrant evidence signals falsity within the conjunction of. The duhemquine thesis asserts that any empirical evaluation of a theory is in fact a composite test of several interconnected hypotheses. Duhem argues that physics is subject to certain methodological limitations that do not affect other sciences. A physical change involves a change in physical properties.
Laws and their role in scientific explanations rs due mon, 1024 philip kitcher. Duhem regarded most theory choices as decidable on empirical grounds, but made historical context the main determining factor in scientific. The duhem thesis and the quine thesis chapter 5, in philosophy of science in the twentieth century. Since physical theory is a representation and not explanation.
Michael polanyi, a very distinguished physical chemist. Physical properties can be observed without changing the type of matter. The aim and structure of physical theory pierre maurice. University of waterloo integ 220, the nature of scientific. The fact that the theory under test and the theory which informs the experimental process coincide by no means make it impossible that. The duhem problem recall achinsteins example from the first reading group hertz had argued that cathode rays are electrically neutral waves of some sort and thus wanted to rule out the hypothesis that they are charged particles h so hertz arranged an experiment to test the hypothesis. Philosophy of science comprehensive exam reading list ayer. Philosophy of science comprehensive exam reading list. Selections from pierre duhem, the aim and structure of physical theory princeton science library edition, 1991, pp. Pierre duhem, in the atm and structure of physical theory, carried machs analysis further by making some distinctions about the varieties of thought experiments. Now that we have minutely analyzed the characteristics of a physical experiment and of a physical law, we can establish the prin. Every experiment involves assumptions about the way in which the measuring instruments function, and these assumptions, in turn, imply physical laws.
1459 923 803 1408 617 1432 138 204 1468 237 763 551 1318 1224 1008 1276 1017 1215 1258 918 907 1062 909 1199 1415 877 1063 1121 295 363 379 347